Aleah Mohammed repeatedly told federal officers that removing her hijab would violate her religious beliefs, and according to a federal lawsuit, her objections were ignored. According to this federal lawsuit, the Muslim woman repeatedly pleaded with officers to respect her religious beliefs, explaining that appearing uncovered before men outside her immediate family violated a practice she had observed for years. Nevertheless, she alleges that officers removed her hijab, photographed her without it, and required her to carry identification displaying the uncovered image throughout her incarceration. The photograph became part of her everyday life, appearing during routine security checks, medical appointments, and other activities she could not avoid. Even after leaving federal custody, Mohammed says the images continued appearing in official records, prolonging an experience she had fought to prevent from the beginning.
On Sept. 30, 2026, Mohammed’s legal challenge reached an important turning point. Judge LaShann DeArcy Hall of the U.S. The District Court for the Eastern District of New York allowed significant portions of her lawsuit to proceed, rejecting the federal defendants’ attempt to have the entire case dismissed. In her decision, the judge recognized that the continued retention and use of photographs taken without Mohammed’s hijab could impose a substantial burden on her religious exercise. The ruling brought renewed attention to a question extending well beyond one woman’s experience—how far can correctional authorities restrict religious practices in the name of institutional security, and what protections remain available to Muslim women once they enter the prison system?
How a routine booking photograph became a religious freedom dispute
The events at the center of Mohammed’s lawsuit began on Sept. 23, 2020, when she was arrested and brought to a federal courthouse in Brooklyn, New York. Mohammed, who had worn the hijab since 2011, arrived wearing both her headscarf and an abaya, a loose-fitting garment that covers the body. According to her complaint, federal agents informed her during processing that she would need to remove her hijab for an identification photograph. She questioned the requirement and explained that removing it in front of unrelated men would violate her religious beliefs. She also requested permission to be photographed while wearing her hijab, but the agents allegedly refused.
Mohammed continued objecting until agents allegedly told her that she would remain detained and would not be arraigned unless she complied. The lawsuit states that FBI Special Agent Meghan Calpin then removed Mohammed’s hijab without her consent while several men were present. A male officer subsequently photographed her. Although her hijab was returned afterward, Mohammed alleges that the image remained in FBI records, where it could potentially be accessed long after the incident. Her ordeal allegedly continued when she was transferred to the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn. There, another officer instructed Mohammed to remove her hijab for a second booking photograph. She again explained why she could not comply, questioning who would be allowed to see the image. According to the complaint, an officer informed her that refusing to remove her hijab would result in her remaining in a holding cell indefinitely. When she learned that Bureau of Prisons staff would be able to view the photograph, she continued to resist the requirement.
The situation became more distressing when Mohammed was required to change into a short-sleeved prison uniform. She requested a garment that would accommodate her religious modesty requirements, but officials allegedly rejected the request. Her hijab and abaya were confiscated, and she was given a towel to use as a substitute. Mohammed maintained that the towel did not adequately cover her hair and neck, leaving her exposed in a manner she considered inconsistent with her faith. According to her complaint, the towel also obstructed part of her face, despite the institution’s stated concern about obtaining a clear identification photograph. Eventually, according to the complaint, a female officer agreed to photograph Mohammed in a private room after the male officers stepped outside. Mohammed says she was assured that the photograph would be used only for identification purposes and would not be viewed by men. Yet moments after the photograph was taken, she alleges that a male officer entered the room and accessed the image on a nearby computer. Mohammed described feeling deceived and deeply humiliated by an accommodation that, from her perspective, had offered little protection.
Following the booking process, Mohammed was placed in solitary confinement for 22 days. The court documents recount this confinement but do not establish that it was imposed as punishment for refusing to remove her hijab. After leaving solitary confinement, she received a prison identification card displaying the uncovered photograph she had repeatedly objected to having taken. One particularly revealing detail appears in the court’s account of what happened afterward. At an unspecified point during her incarceration at the Metropolitan Detention Center, another incarcerated Muslim woman provided Mohammed with a hijab, which she wore for the remainder of her time at that facility. The gesture offered her a way to observe her religious practice after her own headscarf had been confiscated. Yet even with a replacement hijab, Mohammed remained unable to prevent the prison from using photographs that showed her uncovered.
The photograph that continued to haunt Mohammed throughout her time in prison
For Mohammed, the consequences of being photographed without her hijab continued throughout her incarceration. According to her lawsuit, she was required to carry a prison identification card displaying her uncovered image and present it at security checkpoints, medical appointments, and other routine activities. The photograph also allegedly appeared on her locker and in institutional records accessible to male staff. Although Mohammed could wear her hijab within the facility, she had little control over who could view the images taken without it. Mohammed attempted to resolve the matter through the prison’s administrative grievance process, requesting a replacement photograph that respected her religious beliefs. However, her case manager allegedly refused, citing Bureau of Prisons restrictions on religious head coverings in identification photographs. She subsequently filed complaints and appeals but reported receiving no responses within the applicable deadlines.
Despite filing her lawsuit on April 1, 2022, Mohammed alleges that similar violations continued during subsequent transfers. In September 2022, another uncovered photograph was taken at a federal medical facility in Texas, and she claims that U.S. Marshals removed her hijab during transportation, leaving her without one for approximately two weeks. When she was transferred to a federal correctional institution in Danbury, Connecticut, in January 2023, her hijab was allegedly confiscated again. In May 2024, Mohammed was transferred to Brooklyn House, a residential reentry center, where she was finally permitted to wear her hijab for an identification photograph. However, her earlier uncovered images reportedly remained in circulation. According to court documents, she encountered them on staff computers, in records maintained by her case manager, and even in administrative medical records at Brooklyn Hospital. She also reported seeing the photographs in records accessed by her parole officer.
The issue persisted after Mohammed left the residential reentry center in November 2024, and transitioned to probation in May 2025. Although a female probation officer eventually allowed her to take a new photograph while wearing her hijab, Mohammed alleges that her earlier images continued appearing in government records, including those viewed by her male probation officer. Her experience raises a broader question about religious freedom—when an image is obtained in a manner that allegedly violates someone’s religious beliefs, can its continued retention and use prolong that violation?
Are Muslim women allowed to wear hijabs in federal prisons? What do our laws say?
The Federal Bureau of Prisons has an established policy recognizing religious head coverings, including hijabs, as authorized attire for incarcerated women under specified conditions. Its October 24, 2022, Religious Beliefs and Practices program statement permits Muslim women to wear black or off-white hijabs when consistent with institutional security. The policy authorizes up to three scarves or head wraps and generally approves loose-fitting jumper dresses for women who seek to observe religious modesty requirements, provided those accommodations do not compromise institutional security. The same policy instructs prison officials to consider religious practices alongside safety and operational requirements. However, permission to wear a hijab within a correctional facility does not automatically resolve how an institution handles booking photographs, identification records, or security databases. Mohammed’s case illustrates the importance of that distinction. A woman may be allowed to cover her hair during ordinary prison activities while still being instructed to remove her hijab for photographs that become part of her institutional records.
Prison officials have legitimate responsibilities involving identification, security, and the prevention of escapes. The legal dispute concerns whether those objectives justify the particular restrictions imposed on religious practice, especially when less restrictive alternatives may be available. For comparison, the U.S. The Department of State permits religious head coverings in passport photographs under specified conditions, including that the applicant’s full face remains visible. Applicants are generally required to provide a statement explaining that the covering is a religious attire worn daily in public. That policy does not govern prison identification procedures, but it demonstrates that religious attire and official photographic identification are not necessarily incompatible.
The difference between permitting religious clothing and accommodating the associated religious practices is central to Mohammed’s experience. Her complaint raises concerns not only about whether she was permitted to wear her hijab, but also about how correctional authorities handled images that she believed should never have been taken or displayed in the first place.
What does the Religious Freedom Restoration Act say?
At the center of Mohammed’s lawsuit is the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), a federal law enacted in 1993, to protect individuals from unjustified government interference with religious exercise. Under RFRA, 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb-1, the federal government interference cannot substantially burden someone’s religious practice unless it demonstrates that the restriction serves a compelling governmental interest and is the least restrictive means of achieving that interest. This means correctional institutions may need to justify religious restrictions beyond simply citing standard prison procedures. In Mohammed’s case, Judge LaShann DeArcy Hall examined whether the forced removal of her hijab and the continued use of her uncovered photographs violated these protections. In her Sept. 30, 2026, ruling, the judge rejected the federal defendants’ argument that retaining the photographs did not substantially burden Mohammed’s religious exercise.
However, the ruling did not establish that every allegation was true or require the immediate destruction of the photographs. Instead, it allowed Mohammed to continue seeking an injunction restricting their use. The court dismissed her request for an order preventing future uncovered booking photographs because she was no longer incarcerated and had not demonstrated a sufficient likelihood of facing the same procedure again. The judge also granted qualified immunity to individual defendants, protecting them from personal liability because the specific right at issue had not been clearly established under existing precedent. The court left open whether any eventual injunction could extend beyond Mohammed’s individual circumstances or require broader changes to federal prison practices. The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) and CAIR-New York, which represent Mohammed, welcomed the ruling in an Oct. 1, 2026, statement describing it as progress toward protecting their client’s religious rights.
For Mohammed, the ruling represents an important legal victory, but not the end of her case. She has secured the opportunity to continue challenging the government’s use of her uncovered photographs, while the question of whether the courts will ultimately order restrictions on those images remains unresolved.
Denied a hijab behind bars? How Islam in Prison helps address the religious needs of incarcerated Muslims
For incarcerated Muslims, Mohammed’s lawsuit illustrates that entering prison does not automatically extinguish the legal protections surrounding religious exercise. Correctional facilities may impose restrictions necessary for safety and security, but those restrictions remain subject to applicable laws and judicial review. The case also demonstrates the importance of documenting religious accommodation requests and understanding the procedures available for raising concerns. Mohammed’s complaint describes her attempts to obtain a replacement identification photograph and her use of the Bureau of Prisons’ administrative remedy system before pursuing federal litigation. Muslim prisoners experiencing similar difficulties may be able to request accommodations through institutional staff or chaplaincy services, document their concerns through established grievance procedures, and seek assistance from qualified legal representatives or civil rights organizations.
However, legal protections alone do not guarantee that incarcerated Muslims have access to everything they need to practice their faith. Many face challenges obtaining Qurans, prayer rugs, religious clothing, and other essential materials. For Muslim women, access to appropriate head coverings can be particularly important, as Mohammed’s experience demonstrates. Organizations such as Islam in Prison, a division of Al-Furqaan Foundation, are working to address these needs. Through its nationwide outreach efforts, Islam in Prison provides incarcerated Muslims with free copies of The Quran in English, Arabic, and Spanish, alongside Islamic literature and religious essentials such as prayer rugs, hijabs, kufis, and other appropriate items. The organization also works with prison chaplains and correctional staff to facilitate access to religious materials, supports Ramadan and Eid observances, and offers spiritual guidance and reentry assistance to individuals preparing for life after incarceration.
According to Islam in Prison, work extends across federal prisons, state prisons, county jails, and immigration detention facilities. Incarcerated individuals can request religious materials by writing to the organization directly or asking their chaplain to contact its team. By helping Muslims access the resources necessary for worship and religious education, Islam in Prison addresses practical challenges that can otherwise make observing Islam difficult within correctional institutions. Educational resources are also available to help prison officials understand the religious needs of Muslim prisoners. CAIR’s A Correctional Institution’s Guide to Islamic Religious Practices provides guidance on Islamic observances, including prayer, dietary requirements, religious clothing, and other aspects of daily religious life. Such resources can help administrators distinguish between legitimate security concerns and restrictions that may unnecessarily interfere with religious practice.
Beyond the legal questions, Mohamme’s dispute highlights the difficulties of maintaining religious practices in an environment where individuals have limited control over their clothing, privacy, and access to basic necessities. For a Muslim woman who considers wearing the hijab an essential religious obligation, an identification photograph is not necessarily a minor administrative matter. Her case serves as a reminder that protecting religious freedom within prisons involves more than recognizing a person’s right to believe. It also requires meaningful consideration of their ability to practice those beliefs with dignity.
Dua
وَأَيُّوبَ إِذْ نَادَىٰ رَبَّهُۥٓ أَنِّى مَسَّنِىَ ٱلضُّرُّ وَأَنتَ أَرْحَمُ ٱلرَّٰحِمِينَ
“And ˹remember˺ when Job cried out to his Lord, “I have been touched with adversity, and You are the Most Merciful of the merciful.” (The Clear Quran®, 21:83)
Ameen, ya Rabb!